L’Oreal Lash Paradise: An Honest Review

Ever since the launch of this mascara by L’Oreal I knew I wanted to try it! Every beauty review I read mentioned how good it was and even now I still haven’t heard any negatives about it. The mascara is called Lash Paradise in America and has a light pink metallic tube. In The UK, The EU and New Zealand it goes under the name Paradise Extatic and has a rose gold tube.

I purchased my tube of mascara in March off of a website and it cost $19.95, which for a drugstore mascara in New Zealand is very reasonable. In store it costs $25.00 which is still not bad but I’m all about saving money where I can. The website I purchased from actually has the pink tube which I like as pink is my favourite colour. The mascara comes in five different shades that I know of: Blackest Black washable, Black washable, Blackest Brown washable, Blackest Black waterproof and Black waterproof. I purchased Blackest Black washable, I adore super dark lashes and I don’t like waterproof formulas as they are hard to remove. I don’t know if this is true but I’ve heard washable formulas also hold a curl better – can anyone confirm or deny?

A distinctive comparison has been made between L’Oreal’s Lash Paradise and Too Faced’s Better Than Sex. I haven’t tried the Too Faced mascara so I can’t comment but the wands are the same shape and they both have pink, metallic tubes. I’m happy with how Lash Paradise performs so I’m not rushing to try Better Than Sex. Lash Paradise is also half the price.

This mascara has my favourite type of wand, it has proper bristles, not a rubber wand with plastic bristles. The wand is an hourglass shape and is a nice size, it’s not fat and chunky so mascara doesn’t get all around the eyes. The wand is lightweight as well as being easy to hold and manoeuvre.

The formula is great too! I am firmly in the camp that prefers drier mascaras to wet mascaras but even when I first opened this tube and the formula was wet it was fine. I did notice after using the mascara for a couple of weeks the formula changed and it wasn’t as good but when the formula started drying out it went back to applying well again. The not so good period was short lived and hasn’t put me off the product at all.

Two coats is optimum for me – lashes look long and fluttery without clumping and sticking together. The washable formula is a breeze to remove, I simply use a face cloth and it wipes away. The formula doesn’t flake, smudge or wear off throughout the day.

One thing I will say is that the pink metallic coating on the tube does peel away. I’m not sure if the same applies to the rose gold tube, that seems to have a frosted metal finish rather than metallic coating so I wouldn’t assume it does.

I have been using the mascara for four months now and it still performs as well as it did when I first wore it. I’m not someone who keeps mascara for three months then throws them away. As long as the formula isn’t dried up and doesn’t irritate my eyes I will use it. I tend to change mascaras roughly every six months.

Overall I love this mascara! This is on track to knock my favourite Rimmel mascara off the top spot. I definitely see myself repurchasing this which I don’t say for many mascaras and once I’ve been through a couple of tubes I will know if it’s worthy of holy grail status and whether I’ve found a replacement for my Rimmel. I’d like to try Paradise Extatic to see if there are any differences between the two apart from their name – you wouldn’t think so but you never know.

Have you tried this L’Oreal mascara?


Follow me:

Twitter | Instagram | Pinterest

20 thoughts on “L’Oreal Lash Paradise: An Honest Review

  1. alwayscleia says:

    This mascara is my favourite! But $25 in NZ!? That’s so expensive! It’s around $15 here in Canada 😦
    I also noticed that the formula got better as it dried, I went through that weird period where I didn’t like it but then one day it was good again haha

    Liked by 1 person

  2. stashy says:

    I’m always amazed how much you have to pay for stuff there! This costs around $15 here in Canada which is a bit on the high end for drugstore – L’Oreal is one of the more expensive drugstore brands.
    I’m glad you love this mascara – it’s been one of my favourite new mascaras of late. But wow, the metallic coating of the tube isn’t too durable huh! Do you bring your mascara with you in your cosmetic bag?

    Liked by 1 person

    • Chanelle says:

      L’Oreal is on the more expensive end here too. To compare I think this mascara and Maybelline’s Lash Sensational are the same price to buy in store. That price is nothing compared to Too Faced or Benefit. I don’t bring the mascara with me, it sits in my makeup bag on top of a set of drawers.


  3. danniijane says:

    I’ve seen a lot of people say they love this mascara and the packaging is cute. I’ve held off as past L’Oreal mascaras don’t do much for me. I might try it once my current mascaras are finished x

    Liked by 1 person

    • Chanelle says:

      This was the first L’Oreal mascara I’ve ever tried and I’m impressed. If you don’t mind a drier formula and real bristles as opposed to a rubber wand you might enjoy it!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.